Apr 3, 2015 Why are people voting no? If people keep turning down @Koolo's ideas the forum will never grow People were against the gift card idea initially, but that brought in a few new posters
Apr 3, 2015 How about most likes? Or thread with most replies? Seems more indicative of quality content.
Apr 3, 2015 You're already starting to spam stan!! Seriously the idea itself could encourage posting on autopilot like @Kon said but I'm curious what plan @Koolo has with it tbh
Apr 3, 2015 For likes I see it like this: As far as most-replied threads: that is a good idea. As long as the off-topic section isn't included
Apr 3, 2015 completely against it the amount of spam thats gonna go around just for $5 is gonna be insane, especially bot.
Apr 3, 2015 Most replied thread wouldn't work either since that's usually a music related thread and the person who started it has nothing to do with how popular it is. Still think something based off post to likes ratio or likes would make the most sense.
Apr 3, 2015 Seems gimmicky. You're bribing people. That said, f--- it. Forums aren't bastions of integrity.
Apr 3, 2015 Well obviously there'd need to be some discretion on Koolo's part. Likes are just as easily skewed. JCN has a welfare program for them.
Apr 3, 2015 If we were doing something like this I'd rather have people nominate posts/topics for "best of the week" and the winners could get $20 or something.
Apr 3, 2015 I just think that'd create a lot of unnecessary drama with people complaining and upset about stuff. 'That's bs, my thread was the most popular.' 'Yeah but it had nothing to do with your posts, it was cuz your thread was about (insert whatever here).' I don't know, just doesn't seem like the best idea to me. Imo if Koolo wants to give away money/prizes, it should be for a combination of different things including likes, contests, random drawings and maybe a couple other things if anyone has other good ideas. Have different prizes for different things, keep it exciting.
