Dec 1, 2015

Which former Heisman winner would you pick to lead your team to the playoffs in 2016? RG3, the former ROY who took the league by storm in 2012, or Money Manziel? Both have similar styles of play and more than likely will be looking for new teams next year.

Personally I'd go with RG3 given the fact that he led his team to the playoffs his rookie season. Hard to say if he'll ever play that way again, but I think if you surround him by veterans and a good coaching staff he can be successful. Manziel is a wild card and has never really had a chance at the starting job, but I think he can play. His behavior hasn't been nearly as bad as say, Jahlil Okafor, who's gotten away with much worse with basically a slap on the wrist.

 

Dec 1, 2015

Yup, RGIII. He's a proven winner in the NFL. Also seemed to be focused on the game of football more than Johnny Football. Seems like a better leader and safer choice. All of this being said, we've hardly got to see Manziel play... Plus RGIII is so injury prone.

 

Dec 1, 2015

He is, he's a bit more of a prima donna than Johnny is though. I think Manziel deserves a shot, I think he's definitely capable of doing most of the things RG3 can.