Jun 23, 2015 Refill As a whole. Love Forever and Elevator. If Relapse had been songs like. 1. Beautiful 2. Deja Vu 3. My Darling 4. Forever It would have been Goat. But Fine Line and GOF are great. But Refill as a whole> shady Xv
Jun 23, 2015 Shady XV for me if comparing the Refill tracks, the Lose Yourself original demo swings it in its favor, but Relapse + Refill > XV I also think his flow and sound on Detriot vs Everybody was great, i'd probably take it over his verse on Forever.
Jun 23, 2015 Never see much love for h--- Breaks Loose but that song is dope. The beat is fire. Refill > ShadyXV imo
Jun 23, 2015 Most of the songs on Refill should of replaced songs on Relapse. And wth were they thinking when they put My Darling and Careful What You Wish For on the deluxe edition. Those are some of the best tracks. Relapse could have easily been his best album post hiatus and a just a great album period if the bonus tracks and tracks on refill would have replaced some of the s-----y songs on Relapse.
Jun 23, 2015 Î’esides Music Box and Elevator I havent replayed other songs from refill in ages.. Maybe Buffalo Bill from time to time.. Low replay value.. So I go with XV
Jun 23, 2015 Refill has Music Box but ShadyXV has Fine Line. Tough decision. Refill has more songs I like but XV has two really good personal songs which is always appreciated and something refill obviously completely lacks but I'll go with Refill.
Jun 23, 2015 Agree but on the other hand you have fine line and gof.. his lyrics on pk and dve are pretty good imo but his flow is s---. Replay value of both is bad except for a few songs, not sure which I would pick
Jun 23, 2015 Everything on Refill was dope except for taking my ball. I even f----- with DTBOE hard cuz that Dre beat . Everything on Shady XV s----d except for Vegas, GoF and Fine Line.
Jun 23, 2015 ShadyXV didnt happen Naw but seriously Refill is by far the better project, it had much better replay value and songs like Forever/Buffalo Bill/Music Box XV didnt have much, I liked Em's verse on Vegas but it got old pretty fast and Fine Line/Lose Yourself Demo were really nice but thats it. Also production on Refill >>> Beautiful didnt belong anywhere near relapse it was soo out of place and lol no love for serial killers/drugs ?
Jun 24, 2015 if em didn't end the era, he would've descended into total joke territory. and the joke would've gotten old.
Jun 24, 2015 well i mean obviously if you do the same f---ing thing forever its gonna get old and be a joke. still i hope relapse 2 some how leaks some day haha still relapse era was f---ing dope and relapse and refill are f---ing dope albums! Relapse is one of my favs all time (and yes ik its an unpopular opinion)
