Jun 24, 2015

Yeah I really don't agree with its official rating of 96/100... should be more. it's sad that only 5 critics gave Tpab a 11/10 but at the same time it was the first time in music history that critics were ready to give an album a 11/10 rating.


But props to Fantano to say that 2/3 months latter, the album deserves a better score than 10/10.

 

Jun 24, 2015

^but every Kanye album has basically stood the test of time (and in a few years I'm sure yeezus will as well)

 

Jun 24, 2015

I overrated badass and summertime 06.. thought they were 8 but they're 7/10

I underrated TPAB and ALLA. I thought Alla was a 6 but its a 8, And I thought tpab was a 9 but its a 10/10

 

Jun 24, 2015

you are like a whole new level of dickrider. it's kind of staggering.

 

Jun 24, 2015

yeah true about kanye, collegedropout is now being discussed as a dated album and yeezus is one of the most hated albums by the general public (hip hop audience)

 

Jun 24, 2015

this:

 

Jun 24, 2015

@WPG I don't see any dickriding bruh. He is definitely dickriding, a lot of critics who didn't like the album still gave it a perfect score, saying it was impossible to deny its greatness.

 

Jun 24, 2015

are you gunning for worst poster on the board?

overrated: an album that has come out a few months ago being called the best composed piece of music in all of existence, (sans nina simone of course!)


stfu

 

Jun 24, 2015

"he is definitely NOT dickriding"

f---, how come I can''t edit my posts?

 

Jun 24, 2015

Now Kanye West albums... these are definitely SUPER OVERRATED.

 

Jun 24, 2015

i, along with almost every critic i respect (save one or two) gave it poor to middling scores/reviews.

 

Jun 24, 2015

i saw you say that before, what do you mean exactly? once you hit edit...what do you get?

 

Jun 24, 2015

i made the list based off the forum's opinions (that i remembered)

DSP was 100% overrated when it dropped.

what plant do you live on m8

I know music, its not close to the best album of the last 10 years regardless of whatever genre you want to talk about.

and those people are morons

 

Jun 24, 2015

Kanye west himself would agree that his albums have too many flaws to even be considered as great tbh

 

Jun 24, 2015

but cant anyone use the same argument? i with every critic i respect gave it rave reviews ?

 

Jun 24, 2015

@Koolo I just get that message: "ERROR"

 

Jun 24, 2015

i, along with almost every critic i respect (save one or two) gave it poor to middling scores/reviews to Illmatic, MMLP, GRODT, Blueprint, 36 Chambers.

 

Jun 24, 2015

does anyone else have this issue?

 

Jun 24, 2015

IT CANT BE OVERRATED WITHOUT EVEN BEING OUT YET YOU GOOF

Its not even Kendricks best project. The best song on it wouldn't break a top 5 Kendrick songs list. The best verse on it didn't break my top 15 write up

this is hilarious

Lock this thread because fuckwads like you think TPAB is "the best album of the last 10 years, IF you know music that is?"

yeah sure lmfao

 

Jun 24, 2015

I think the only albums that deserve their goat status (huge fan of music here, I really know my s---) are Outkast, Atliens, Ready To Die, TPAB, supreme clientele, F&L.

The rest = overrated s---